The National Football League is the best and most popular sport going these days. The collective bargaining agreement currently being worked on is an opportunity to bring forth more positive change. Many changes have happened already under the current commissioner Roger Goodell. I am not saying they are all good changes but he is certainly a man of action.
The commissioner wants to implement an 18 game regular season citing the fans distaste for pre-season games as the main reason. We all know it is really all about the money but I am here to tell you that the result of all of this could be great.
The main disagreement between players and owners comes down to money. The players want a bigger piece of the pie. The owners need a bigger piece of the pie to keep each franchise profitable. The obvious solution is to "expand the pie" and it looks like the 18 game regular season is the best way to do this. it appears that it is going to happen. My thought here is that this presents an opportunity to eliminate a situation where a losing team like Seattle makes the playoffs.
I would like to see four divisions of eight teams replace the current format of eight divisions of four teams. Under this new format a team who wins a large division gets a first round bye automatically. If it stays as six teams from each conference in the playoffs they should all be seeded according to won-lost record. This format would be better and fairer and eliminate all losing teams from making the playoffs. There would be many details to be worked out but I am asking you to vote on the basic idea of larger divisions. Do you like it?
Remembering that geographically it never has made sense to have Dallas in the East, I am not too concerned with that part right now. I am keeping it simple for the sake of discussion. One idea I came up with is to have an AFC East of NE, NYJ, MI, BF, PT, BT, CL, and CN with KC, SD, OK, DN, ID, JK, TN, and HU in the AFC West. The NFC East could consist of AT, NO, TB, CR, PH, NYG, WA, and DL and in the NFC West would be CH, GB, DT, MN, SE, SL, SF, and AZ.
Under this format here is how the playoff seeding would look (1-6) compared to what they are now if all the teams had their current records:
NE, PT, ID, KC, BT, NYJ
becomes
NE*, PT, BT, NYJ, KC*, ID
AT, CH, PH, SE, NO, GB
becomes
AT*, NO, CH*, GB, PH, NYG
In the AFC the same six teams get in but we would have ID at PT and NYJ at BT. As division winners NE and KC get the first round byes.
In the NFC the Giants (10-6) sneak in while the Seahawks (7-9) are left out. The Wild card round would be NYG at NO and PH at GB while division winners AT and CH rest. The teams with the better records should be, and now are, playing at home.
The entire schedule would be different so often times the division winners would also wind up seeded 1 and 2 which will make it even better. I would like to see a new 18 game schedule include 14 games within each teams division. Teams would play every other member of their large divisions twice. I suggest that the other four games would match up each division winner from the previous season with the other three division winners. The second place teams would all meet and on down the line. There are many things that could be done with that one remaining game. I would love to see a situation where the first week of the season is all NFC vs. AFC and the season opens with some heavyweight match ups. This conference showdown would be a great way to see which conference appears stronger.
Maybe the bye weeks for the entire AFC could be weeks 5 and 15 and the entire NFC would be off in weeks 6 and 16 or something like that. This would give us only 8 games during four of the NFL weekends but a full 16 games on the other sixteen weekends. It is a win/win: better for the fans and fairer for the players and the competitive balance between the teams. Roger Goodell always says that it is important to help the players stay as healthy as possible.
I would also think the game day rosters should be expanded from 45 to over 50 players and the overall roster expanded to 60. This would also employ more players and teams would not find themselves short handed at a particular position as often even though more games are played and more injuries occur. Again, these are all details to be negotiated. Right now just give me your thoughts on my basic idea of larger divisions to keep losing teams out. Do you like it?